washingtonia robusta how hardy
Forum rules
This area is for Reference and discussion of plant hardiness, overwintering methods and tips, and planr protection.
This area is for Reference and discussion of plant hardiness, overwintering methods and tips, and planr protection.
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
Dont worry its not going out its more 5 c I have the jungle seeds 2008 so are get the ricinus seeds from that book . CHEERS
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
Hi Nathan, how big is the washy and the Phoenix canariensis_CIDP behind? I have never seen pics of these before but that surely is a great picture.Nathan wrote:If you live in the city limits of Southampton itself it should be fine outside, even as a small plant. If you live more out in the suburbs then it may need protecting in colder weather. As has been said robusta can take damp/wet weather better than filifera, so are more suited to our climate, though they are not quite as hardy as filifera. Washingtonia robustas seem to be popping up around Portsmouth in the last couple of years, (B&Q to thank I guess), mine has been out for 6 years & was only around 18 inches high when first planted. Its now huge & has giant leaves... They are very fast growing & even if the leaves get damaged by frost they will quickly grow new ones the following summer...derrick wrote:8c thats ok then i might put it outside spring .I dont want to shock it to much now And they can deal with the rain.
Pic from back bedroom showing Washingtonia robusta starting to get up over the top of the kitchen roof...
Last edited by Axel on Sun Dec 14, 2008 10:39 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Dave Brown
- Site Admin
- Posts: 19742
- Joined: Sun Jul 09, 2006 10:17 am
- Location: Chalk, (Thames Estuary) Kent, England 51.5N 0.3E
- Contact:
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
I would say no more than -6C for a big W.robusta, but it can tolerate more winter wet. It is not as hardy as Phoenix canariensis_CIDP but can grow out winter damage very fast. My Washie has only ever had -6.1C and was totally defoliated
I would be worried if we were forecast -8C Mine is not small... mature and now growing a trunk.
I would be worried if we were forecast -8C Mine is not small... mature and now growing a trunk.
Best regards
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
I can say that Robusta will see -9 if dry as that was the temperature acheived in my green house earlier this year
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
Axel,Axel wrote:Hi Nathan, how big is the washy and the Phoenix canariensis_CIDP behind? I have never seen pics of these before but that surely is a great picture.Nathan wrote:If you live in the city limits of Southampton itself it should be fine outside, even as a small plant. If you live more out in the suburbs then it may need protecting in colder weather. As has been said robusta can take damp/wet weather better than filifera, so are more suited to our climate, though they are not quite as hardy as filifera. Washingtonia robustas seem to be popping up around Portsmouth in the last couple of years, (B&Q to thank I guess), mine has been out for 6 years & was only around 18 inches high when first planted. Its now huge & has giant leaves... They are very fast growing & even if the leaves get damaged by frost they will quickly grow new ones the following summer...derrick wrote:8c thats ok then i might put it outside spring .I dont want to shock it to much now And they can deal with the rain.
Pic from back bedroom showing Washingtonia robusta starting to get up over the top of the kitchen roof...
My Washie is around 8-9ft tall overall. It has a thick 4-5ft trunk & leaves around a metre across. It was planted out in 2002 as an 18 inch plant...
The Phoenix canariensis_CIDP is a bit taller & its leaves span the width of my tiny garden, it was planted in 2003 as a 4ft plant purchased from a supermarket. Unfortunately due to the size of my garden its hard to get a decent shot of them & every pic I try to take I cannot get the whole plant into shot
- Dave Brown
- Site Admin
- Posts: 19742
- Joined: Sun Jul 09, 2006 10:17 am
- Location: Chalk, (Thames Estuary) Kent, England 51.5N 0.3E
- Contact:
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
year-but...... the only place to get to -9C and be dry is inside a greenhouse. Highly unlikely outsidegrub wrote:I can say that Robusta will see -9 if dry as that was the temperature acheived in my green house earlier this year
Best regards
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk
- Las Palmas Norte
- Posts: 1892
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 7:17 pm
- Location: Lantzville, British Columbia (Vancouver Island)
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
All this has me believing you're not likley to see Washingtonia robust become a skyline tree in most parts of England. Am I mistaken, or are there some tall unprotected skyline or large sized specimen there?
Considering they're fast growers I'd be inclined to think big robusta would be easy over the past decade or more.
Cheers, Barrie.
Considering they're fast growers I'd be inclined to think big robusta would be easy over the past decade or more.
Cheers, Barrie.
- Dave Brown
- Site Admin
- Posts: 19742
- Joined: Sun Jul 09, 2006 10:17 am
- Location: Chalk, (Thames Estuary) Kent, England 51.5N 0.3E
- Contact:
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
Barrie, I live in what now seems to be a coastal climate rather than an inland one having the information on other weathersattions. I think Washingtinia robusta is marginal in UK coastal climates, ie, you need a good microclimate as well to guarantee success. The thing is, that even here temps were too cold for Washingtonia. I lost a 4 foot tall specimen in the winter of 1984/5 and would have been hard pressed to get a Washie through the megacold snap in Jan 1987 (-12.9C) Since that time we have got away with it here, with coldest temps being about -8C and coldest since 2000 -6C.
I think large mature specimens (trunk forming) would come back from total defoliation at -8C, but very few people had large ones 10 years ago, so small ones were planted out and in most cases, lost I am hoping that as the palm gets taller the growing point is further from the very cold ground layer. As my Washie had the protection of a west facing wall, it has grown large enough now to fend for itself and is growing around 1 foot of trunk and 20 leaves per year. Every spring I breath a sigh of relief that it has made another year. I still expect to lose it at some point, but it looks impressive while I still have it.
My advice to anyone thinking of planting one out would be don't be in too much of a hurry, let it bulk up in a pot, when planting out choose a sunny place protected from cold winds, and give overhead protection when forecast below -3C. I have not used rain shelters, but that is one form of overhead protection. I draped fleece over the top while small enough just to stop too much leaf damage. Once established it's speed of growth is it's main salvation, as it is quick to grow out any winter damage.
Once above about 6 feet it is not possible to give overhead protection, but as said, hopefully by that stage it will cope with the coldest weather we have here.
I think large mature specimens (trunk forming) would come back from total defoliation at -8C, but very few people had large ones 10 years ago, so small ones were planted out and in most cases, lost I am hoping that as the palm gets taller the growing point is further from the very cold ground layer. As my Washie had the protection of a west facing wall, it has grown large enough now to fend for itself and is growing around 1 foot of trunk and 20 leaves per year. Every spring I breath a sigh of relief that it has made another year. I still expect to lose it at some point, but it looks impressive while I still have it.
My advice to anyone thinking of planting one out would be don't be in too much of a hurry, let it bulk up in a pot, when planting out choose a sunny place protected from cold winds, and give overhead protection when forecast below -3C. I have not used rain shelters, but that is one form of overhead protection. I draped fleece over the top while small enough just to stop too much leaf damage. Once established it's speed of growth is it's main salvation, as it is quick to grow out any winter damage.
Once above about 6 feet it is not possible to give overhead protection, but as said, hopefully by that stage it will cope with the coldest weather we have here.
Best regards
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
My washy has or rather had been in the ground for 3 years, the first couple of years it had a rain shelter built over it for the winter. Last year it was to tall and this along with it's spread and proximity to other large plants meant that a rain shelter was not practical so all it got was a couple of old summer weight duvets thrown over it during the coldest night (min -6c), its now potted up on our deck ready to move. The pergola over the deck has allowed me to put a temporary shelter over it for this winter
Not a great pic but gives an indication of its size
Gary
Not a great pic but gives an indication of its size
Gary
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
This one is outside amsterdam next to the building of a palmwholsaler. Completely exposed and experienced around -7/-8C.
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
That's a biggun Axel Is it planted out? How long has it been there??
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
I have only noticed it last summer and it has come through our last winter completely defoliated. I have seen -6.7C last winter so i geuss this one experienced a degree or 2 lower since its so far from any city and its completely exposed. It's planted in a pot about 2 times the size of the trunk.
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
I wonder how big Washies are likely to get over here? I doubt even in milder areas they will get as big as the one in your pic?? I'm surprised there are not big ones on Tresco. The biggest ones I have seen are at the Ventnor Botanic Garden on the Isle of Wight...Axel wrote:I have only noticed it last summer and it has come through our last winter completely defoliated. I have seen -6.7C last winter so i geuss this one experienced a degree or 2 lower since its so far from any city and its completely exposed. It's planted in a pot about 2 times the size of the trunk.
Last edited by Nathan on Tue Dec 16, 2008 1:17 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
I spend some time looking at washy experiences in Dallas and if you look at the growth rate overthere than you realise they really like HEAT, dry heat. Dave's washy has been a great inspiration for me and i bought a similar sized one, but in Dallas i think they reach that size from a tiny plant within 2 or 3 years.
By the way, Dallas is around 0C today but turns to 25C again in the next 2 days. They have some colder nights than most of the UK and they cant keep Phoenix canariensis_CIDP's alive outside the center of town. Their Washie robusta's have full crowns again by april.
By the way, Dallas is around 0C today but turns to 25C again in the next 2 days. They have some colder nights than most of the UK and they cant keep Phoenix canariensis_CIDP's alive outside the center of town. Their Washie robusta's have full crowns again by april.
- Dave Brown
- Site Admin
- Posts: 19742
- Joined: Sun Jul 09, 2006 10:17 am
- Location: Chalk, (Thames Estuary) Kent, England 51.5N 0.3E
- Contact:
Re: washingtonia robusta how hardy
I remember i was enthusing at my washie growing 18 leaves in 2006, and a guy living on an island off the coast of Croasia took the wind out of my sails as he had 46 leaves in the same period So even in places with just a few degrees more heat the difference can be dramatic. If Tresco does not have a summer as such they may be down to 10 leaves or less. May here is as warm as Tresco in July, and May is my 5th warmest month on average, so I may have 4 or 5 months better growing conditions.
At it's present rate of growth it will be around 20 feet in 2018. freezes excepted, but at some point it's height will keep it mainly above the frost level. It grew 20 leaves this year and was not as hot as most recent years, although unlike some unfortunates further north we did have a summer.
At it's present rate of growth it will be around 20 feet in 2018. freezes excepted, but at some point it's height will keep it mainly above the frost level. It grew 20 leaves this year and was not as hot as most recent years, although unlike some unfortunates further north we did have a summer.
Best regards
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk
Dave
_________________________________________________
Roll on summer.....
http://www.hardytropicals.co.uk